Mortgage Prison 2026: Negative Equity and Sydney Property

BORROWERS IN NEGATIVE EQUITYEach grid is 100 Australian mortgagesTODAYUnder 1 in 100AT A FURTHER −20%About 5 in 100Each dot is one mortgage. Reserve Bank of Australia, Financial Stability Review, October 2026. NEGATIVE EQUITYEach grid is 100 mortgagesTODAYUnder 1 in 100AT A FURTHER −20%About 5 in 100Each dot is one mortgage.RBA Financial Stability Review,October 2026.
Market commentary · November 2026

Fewer than one in a hundred are trapped. If you are one of them, it decides everything.

I wrote a piece about the mortgage prison — owners who can no longer afford to sell, refinance or move. The Equifax warning behind it is real and the phrase is a direct quote. But when I checked the Reserve Bank review I had cited as my own source, it says the problem is far smaller than my draft implied. That changes the article, and it does not change the advice.

<1%
Share of Australian mortgage borrowers currently in negative equity, on the RBA’s own estimate. It would take a further 20% fall in prices to push that to about 5%.
01 · What the recheck found

The arithmetic was right. The scale was not.

The worked example in my draft computes correctly to the dollar, which I was pleased about and slightly surprised by. The problem is everything around it: I cited a Reserve Bank review that contradicts the impression my own article gives.

The implication that this is widespread enough to break the transaction chain.
Contradicted by my own source

The October 2026 Financial Stability Review puts borrowers in negative equity at below 1%, and estimates that even a further uniform 20% fall in prices would lift that to only about 5%. The RBA’s words are that negative equity “is insufficient to trigger default if borrowers remain able to service their loans, which remains the case for the vast majority of these households”. It also reports that bank liaison suggests hardship among 5% Deposit Scheme participants remains contained. My draft gestured at family homes and higher price points being dragged in. The evidence does not support that.

“$1.1m purchase, 5% deposit, balance down to $1.02m after two years.”
Correct to within $150

I checked this properly. A $1,045,000 loan over thirty years at about 6.5% amortises to $1,020,857 after twenty-four monthly payments. The draft said $1.02 million. That one holds, and so does the uncomfortable conclusion that follows from it.

An apartment bought for $1.1m, now worth about $1m.
A 9% fall, on the resilient half of the market

Sydney units fell 5.6% over the year to October against 10.8% for houses. Units are the part of this market holding up best, so applying a house-sized fall to an apartment needs saying out loud. It is still realistic for particular stock — I have seen Bondi Junction apartments advertised around $400,000 below their off-the-plan purchase price — but that is a specific kind of apartment, not the median one, and the example should say so.

“This is sometimes referred to as a mortgage prison.”
It is a quote, so attribute it

The phrase comes from Equifax executive general manager Moses Samaha, who said first-home buyers facing both high arrears and falling valuations “may start to feel that their homeownership dream is becoming a mortgage prison”. Note the construction: may start to feel. That is a good deal more careful than reporting it as an established condition, and the care belongs in my article too.

“Refinancing options may be limited.”
True, and there is a number for it

Equifax has measured it. Refinancing demand among borrowers aged 26 to 35 fell 14.2% in the year to September, while demand among those aged 56 to 60 and over 60 moved slightly higher. That is the whole argument in one statistic: older owners with equity keep their options, recent buyers with thin equity lose them. My draft asserted it without the evidence that was sitting there.

Nothing on who is actually affected.
The data identifies them quite precisely

Equifax found the risk concentrated among 5% Deposit Scheme buyers who started at loan-to-value ratios around 95%, and split by industry: those in rate-sensitive and discretionary sectors are considerably more likely to be in arrears than those in stable or higher-income work. A piece that says “some owners” when the source identifies which owners is leaving out the useful part.

02 · Who is actually trapped

Not the market. A very particular slice of it.

Every figure below is from the two sources my original piece named. Together they describe a problem that is narrow, concentrated and severe for the people inside it.

95%
Starting loan-to-value ratio

Typical for buyers who came in through the Australian Government 5% Deposit Scheme. At that gearing, even a modest price fall takes the equity to nothing. The guarantee removed the need for lenders mortgage insurance on the way in; it does nothing on the way out.

−14.2%
Refinancing demand, ages 26–35

Year to September 2026. Over the same period, demand from borrowers aged 56 to 60 and over 60 rose slightly. Equity is what buys you the right to shop around, and the people who most need a better rate are the ones who cannot go and get one.

−22.1%
First-home buyer mortgage demand

Year on year in September, against −19.2% across all mortgage demand. The entry point of the chain is thinning faster than the rest of it, which is the real mechanism by which this reaches owners further up.

About 5%
Negative equity at a further −20%

The RBA’s stress scenario. Worth holding both facts at once: one in twenty mortgages under a severe further fall is a serious number for the country, and it is still nineteen in twenty who are fine.

Two cautions on the reassuring number
  • New loans have not been tested yet. The RBA notes that arrears on recently originated loans may understate eventual performance, because those loans have had less time to meet an income or expenditure shock. The sub-1% is a measurement of today, not a forecast.
  • Negative equity only matters if you must move. That is the point the aggregate statistic cannot capture. An owner with thin equity who is happy where they are has a number on a page. An owner with thin equity whose family has outgrown the apartment has a problem that no national average describes.
03 · Where you actually stand

Your equity, after the costs of selling

Most people estimate their equity by subtracting the loan from a guess at the value. That skips the part that decides whether you can move: agent fees and legal costs come out before you see a dollar.

$1,100,000
5%
6.50%
2
−9.0%
Loan balance now
$1,020,857
From $1,045,000
Value now
$1,001,000
Down $99,000
Equity on paper
−$19,857
Value less the loan
After selling costs
−$39,877
Allowing 2% to sell

Principal and interest over thirty years at a constant rate, no offset, no redraw and no extra repayments — so it is conservative on the balance and generous on nothing. Selling costs allowed at 2% for agent fees and legals. Excludes break costs, discharge fees and any lenders mortgage insurance that would be payable again on a new loan. Indicative only and not advice; your lender’s valuation is the one that counts.

My read

The statistic that matters to the Reserve Bank and the statistic that matters to you are different statistics, and both are correct. Under one per cent is a sound financial system. It is no comfort whatsoever to the couple in a two-bedroom apartment with a second child on the way, and in thirty-five years those are the conversations I remember. What I would say to anyone in that position is this: find out the real number now, while you still have time to do something with it. The worst version of this is not having thin equity. It is discovering you have thin equity in the week you have to move.

04 · The chain

How one stalled apartment reaches a Bellevue Hill house

The mechanism in my original piece was right even though I overstated its scale. Here it is properly, and with the figure that actually drives it — first-home buyer demand down 22.1% in a year.

01
A first-home buyer purchases the entry-level apartment
Except demand from that group fell 22.1% over the year to September, and those who are active are borrowing less. The bottom rung is thinner, not absent.
02
That seller upgrades to a townhouse or larger apartment
Only if the sale clears their loan and leaves a deposit. With a 95% starting LVR and a two-year hold, it may not — and the move stops here rather than passing upward.
03
That seller moves into a house
This is where the house-and-unit split bites. They are selling into the segment that fell 5.6% and buying into the one that fell 10.8%, which works in their favour, if they can get out at all.
04
The house owner downsizes into a premium apartment
And finds the buyer pool for their house thinner than it was, because the rungs below have not cleared. This is the only point at which a stalled entry-level market reaches a $4m house, and it is indirect.

The chain is real and it is slower than it was. What it is not, on the current evidence, is broken. A 19.2% fall in overall mortgage demand describes a market with fewer transactions, not one that has stopped — and I set out what that means for choosing an agent in my piece on the worst lending quarter on record.

05 · Sell first

The strategy that worked for a decade is the dangerous one now

Buying before selling made sense when your property was rising while you waited. The arithmetic of that bet has inverted, and the penalty for losing it has grown.

$150,000
The gap in my worked example

An owner buys at $2.5m expecting $1.8m for their existing home, and the offers come in at $1.65m. That gap has to be funded from somewhere, and the somewhere is usually bridging finance at a rate above your home loan.

39 days
National median time on market

The highest since August 2020. Every assumption about how long a bridging arrangement needs to run was built in a faster market. Vendor discounting is at 4.7%, the widest since May 2019.

$118,788
Transfer duty on that $2.5m purchase

NSW 2026–27 scale. It does not change the size of the gap, but it changes the total you must fund, and in my experience it is the number people forget when they work out whether they can afford to buy first.

The right to say no
What you are really buying

A seller with a settlement date cannot reject a low offer, and every experienced buyer in the room can tell. Selling first costs you the convenience of one move. It buys you the only negotiating position that works in this market.

None of which makes buying first always wrong — it depends on your buffer, your deadline and how distinctive the property you are chasing is. If the two transactions genuinely have to happen together, that is a timing problem with a solution, and it is how I coordinate a sale and a purchase as one move. Where the market sits right now is in my November update on the house and unit split, and if you are weighing the timing itself, I have set out what waiting another year actually costs.

06 · What to do about it

Find out the number before you need it

If you expect to move in the next year or two, there are three things worth knowing now rather than later. What your property would realistically achieve in this market, which is not what the portal estimate says and not what the neighbour got in 2021. What your loan balance actually is, which your lender will tell you in about four minutes. And what is left after agent fees, legal costs and discharging the loan — the number in the calculator above, with your own figures in it.

If that comes out positive, you have options and you can take your time choosing between them. If it comes out thin or negative, you have found out while you can still do something: extra repayments, a longer runway, a different target property, or simply a decision to stay put for two more years made deliberately rather than discovered at the worst moment. Either way you are deciding with a number instead of a hope. For apartment owners, the building matters more than the suburb — strata finances, upcoming capital works and defect history move your valuation more than the index does, and I work through that building by building across the Bondi Junction apartment market.

Not sure what your property would actually clear? Let’s work it out.

What it would realistically sell for today, what comes off the top, and what is left against your loan. No obligation to sell, and if the answer is that you should stay put for two more years I will tell you that and explain why. Thirty-five years in the Eastern Suburbs, every campaign run personally.

Alan Weiss
Principal, Weiss Real Estate · 35 years in the Eastern Suburbs
alan@weissrealestate.com.au · 0412 176 074
Sources
  1. Reserve Bank of Australia, Financial Stability Review, October 2026, released 1 October — share of borrowers in negative equity, the 20% stress scenario, and commentary on 5% Deposit Scheme participants and recently originated loans.
  2. Equifax analysis of Australian Government 5% Deposit Scheme borrowers, reported 2 November 2026 — loan-to-value ratios, arrears split by industry, and the negative equity warning.
  3. Moses Samaha, executive general manager, Equifax Australia — the “mortgage prison” remark, November 2026.
  4. Equifax mortgage demand data, September quarter 2026 — overall demand down 19.2% year on year, first-home buyer demand down 22.1%.
  5. Equifax refinancing demand by age cohort, year to September 2026 — borrowers aged 26 to 35 down 14.2%; demand among those 56 and over slightly higher.
  6. Cotality Home Value Index, October 2026 — Sydney house and unit annual changes, median time on market and vendor discounting.
  7. Revenue NSW transfer duty rates, 2026–27 general and premium property scales.
  8. Weiss Real Estate transaction records and campaign files, Sydney Eastern Suburbs, 1991 to 2026.

This article is general market commentary and is not personal financial, credit, taxation or legal advice. The worked examples are illustrative and do not represent actual clients or establish the prevalence of mortgage distress. Equity, balance and selling-cost calculations are indicative: your lender’s valuation, your loan contract and your own costs are what decide the outcome. If you are under financial pressure, speak to your lender’s hardship team, a financial counsellor or the National Debt Helpline before making a decision about your home. Alan Weiss, Weiss Real Estate. Figures current at 13 November 2026.

Related Posts