The first-home buyers didn’t leave. The investors did.
I wrote a piece asking where the first-home buyers have gone. Both figures in it are right. But the same ABS release contains a sentence that answers my own headline, and the answer is that they have not gone anywhere.
Every figure held. The premise did not.
The 8.6% quarterly fall and the 12.3% annual fall are both exactly right, and the repayment calculation is correct to the dollar. The problem is the question I asked at the top, and an omission that changes who the article is actually about.
Its words: owner-occupier first home buyers “continued to account for more than one-third of owner occupier commitments, remaining a significant share of owner occupier lending”. They fell 8.6% in the quarter. Investors fell 30.6%. Over the year, first home buyers are down 12.3% against 38.5% for investors and 21.4% for the market as a whole. First home buyers are not the group that left. On the numbers they are now a larger share of a smaller market, which is close to the opposite of what my headline implied.
Straight from the ABS media release of 11 November. Worth adding the sentence that follows it in the original: this came after a 4.4% fall in the June quarter, not the 2.2% that several news reports carried. When the secondary coverage disagrees with the primary release, the release wins.
At 6.75% on $1.14m over thirty years the repayment is $7,394 a month and $88,728 a year. Both right. But no lender approves on that figure. APRA requires every regulated lender to assess at three percentage points above the actual rate, a setting reaffirmed at its July 2026 review. The buyer in my example is tested at around 10.1%, where the assessed repayment is $10,089 a month. That is the number that decides whether they get the loan, and my draft never mentioned it.
The cash rate went to 4.85% on 3 November, which puts a standard variable nearer 7.1%. A 95% loan-to-value loan is also priced above standard, so a 5% deposit buyer is paying more again. At 7.1% the repayment is $7,661 a month rather than $7,394, and the assessment rate climbs with it.
APRA also holds lenders to a six-times debt-to-income limit. A $1.14m loan therefore needs a household income of at least $190,000 before the application is even looked at. At that income the assessed repayments come to 64% of gross, which no lender will write — so the real income required is considerably higher than the cap implies. Two separate tests, and my article discussed neither.
Sydney’s median unit value is about $857,872. A $1.2m apartment is an Eastern Suburbs price, not a first-home-buyer price, and using it makes the affordability gap look like a market-wide problem when it is partly a question of which apartment. The argument is stronger, not weaker, if it says so.
Rank the four groups and the story inverts
Switch between the quarter and the year. On both measures, first home buyers are closer to the resilient end than the collapsing one.
The September quarter in full
| Borrower | Loans written | Quarter | Year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Owner occupiers | 76,578 | −5.3% | −9.8% |
| — of which first home buyers | 26,415 | −8.6% | −12.3% |
| Investors | 35,301 | −30.6% | −38.5% |
| All borrowers | 111,878 | −15.0% | −21.4% |
| Value of all lending | $81.2bn | −15.5% | −18.1% |
ABS Lending Indicators, September quarter 2026, seasonally adjusted, released 11 November. Dwelling commitments exclude refinancing. First home buyer figures are owner-occupier first home buyers; the ABS publishes a separate and much smaller first home buyer investor series.
- −12.3% is ABS loan commitments. Loans actually written over the year. It counts people who got to the other side of an approval.
- −22.1% is Equifax mortgage demand. Enquiries and applications over the same period, the largest annual drop since December 2022. It counts people who tried.
- The gap between them is the story. Interest fell by roughly a fifth, but completed loans fell by an eighth — because the ones who proceeded were the ones who could already clear the assessment. The buyers who disappeared were never going to finance your apartment anyway.
Your buyer is assessed at a rate they will never pay
This is the part most vendors never see. The repayment your buyer can comfortably afford is not the repayment the bank tests them on. Set a price and a deposit, then look at the gap between the middle two figures.
APRA requires regulated lenders to assess at three percentage points above the actual rate and holds them to a six-times debt-to-income limit. Both settings were reaffirmed at the July 2026 review. Non-bank lenders are not bound by APRA’s buffer and some apply a smaller one, usually at a higher interest rate. Individual lenders apply their own policies on top, so the same application produces different answers at different banks. Illustrative only, and not a loan assessment.
I have had this conversation with vendors more times than I can count and it never lands the first time. You price the apartment at what a buyer can afford, and the bank prices it at what a buyer could afford if rates went up another three points. The gap between those two numbers is roughly $2,400 a month on the example above, and it is invisible from the outside. It is why an inspection full of enthusiastic people can produce no offers, and why the one buyer who does proceed is often the one who looked least excited. They had already been to the bank.
The buyer pool is smaller, and better financed
In Bondi Junction, Bondi, Randwick, Coogee and Edgecliff, first home buyers are a meaningful part of the market for one and two-bedroom apartments. The practical change is not that they have disappeared, but that the ones left have already passed the test.
26,415 of 76,578 in the September quarter. The ABS describes them as remaining a significant share of lending, and that share has risen as investors have withdrawn.
Against 10.8% for houses. The segment first home buyers actually buy is the one that has held up best, which is a point in a vendor’s favour and worth making at the appraisal.
Up from $731,000 in June, even as the number of loans fell. Fewer buyers, each borrowing more: the marginal buyer has dropped out and the well-financed remain.
Treasury’s stated intent is to help first home buyers compete for established homes. On the September figures that is working, at least in the sense that investors have stepped back from exactly that market.
What follows from this for a seller is narrower than “the buyers have gone” and more useful. You will see fewer people at an inspection, and a smaller proportion of those who do come will be financed. The ones who are financed have been assessed at a rate three points above what they will pay, so they know their ceiling precisely and will not move above it for atmosphere. Competitive tension has to be built deliberately rather than hoped for, and the qualifying conversation matters more than the number of attendees. I have set out what that means for choosing an agent in my piece on the worst lending quarter on record, and the building-level detail that moves an apartment price — strata finances, capital works, defect history — is worked through building by building across the Bondi Junction apartment market.
You are not waiting for a better price. You are waiting for a different buyer pool.
The example in my draft holds up. An owner who could sell at $1.2m today and holds out for $1.3m, in a market that falls a further 5%, is looking at $1.14m — $60,000 behind where they started, before holding costs.
What I would add is that the price is the smaller half of it. The buyers who were qualified to purchase six months ago have either bought elsewhere or been re-assessed at a higher rate, and an approval has a shelf life. You are not holding an asset and waiting for its number to improve. You are holding it while the specific people who could have bought it are replaced by different people with different borrowing capacity, and there is no mechanism that returns the originals to you.
That said, the case against waiting is not automatic. Whether it makes sense depends far more on the direction of your next move than on the market itself, and I have run the arithmetic on both sides — including the one scenario where a falling market works in your favour — in what waiting another year actually costs. If thin equity is part of the picture, that is a different problem again, and I have set it out in the piece on negative equity.
- Find out what your apartment would realistically achieve now. Not the portal estimate. Comparable sales in your building and the two streets around it, with the ones that are genuinely comparable separated from the ones that merely look it.
- Understand who can finance it. At your likely price, what household income does a buyer need to clear the assessment? If that number is far above what your buyer profile earns, the price is the problem rather than the campaign.
- Give yourself three or four months, not four weeks. A seller with time can decline an offer. A seller with a settlement date cannot, and every experienced buyer in the room can tell the difference. The forces beyond interest rates decide more of your outcome than the cash rate does.
Wondering who can actually afford your apartment? Let’s work out the buyer.
What your property would realistically achieve, what income a buyer needs to clear the assessment at that price, and whether the pool of people who can is big enough to create competition. If the honest answer is that the price needs to move, I will tell you and show you why. Thirty-five years in the Eastern Suburbs, every campaign run personally.
- Australian Bureau of Statistics, Lending Indicators, September quarter 2026, released 11 November 2026 — loan commitment numbers and values by borrower type, quarterly and through the year.
- ABS media release, Largest quarterly falls on record led by loans to investors, 11 November 2026 — the 4.4% June quarter figure and the first home buyer share of owner-occupier commitments.
- Australian Prudential Regulation Authority — three percentage point serviceability buffer and six times debt-to-income limit, reaffirmed at the July 2026 macroprudential review.
- Equifax mortgage demand data, year to September 2026 — first home buyer demand down 22.1%, largest annual fall since December 2022.
- Cotality Home Value Index, October 2026 — Sydney house and unit annual changes and median unit value.
- Australian Treasury — negative gearing limited to new builds from 1 July 2027.
- Weiss Real Estate transaction records and campaign files, Sydney Eastern Suburbs, 1991 to 2026.
This article is general market commentary and is not personal financial, credit, taxation or legal advice, and nothing here is a loan assessment or a statement of any lender’s policy. Repayment, assessment and income figures are illustrative calculations on a thirty-year principal-and-interest loan at a constant rate; individual lenders apply their own policies and the same application will produce different answers at different banks. Lending figures are seasonally adjusted and subject to revision. Seek advice specific to your circumstances before acting. Alan Weiss, Weiss Real Estate. Figures current at 13 November 2026.