Property or ETFs? The investment equation has changed.
By Alan Weiss | Sydney Eastern Suburbs real estate
The 2027 environment: a tighter equation
For most of my career, residential property was treated as Australia’s default wealth strategy. Buy well, borrow prudently and give the asset time. Today my conversations with investors are more measured. Is property still worth the risk? Have the rules changed? Should I diversify into ETFs?
My answer is not that property is dead. It is that the numbers must work. Interest costs, strata levies, insurance, land tax and maintenance can absorb a large share of rental income. A strong rental market does not guarantee a profitable investment. In my Sydney property market analysis, I distinguish between demand for housing and the financial capacity to buy it.
Who owns Australia’s rental property?
ATO individual tax statistics have historically shown that roughly seven in ten individual rental-property investors report an interest in just one property. The original article estimated 2.2–2.3 million investors; these are historical approximate figures, not a verified November 2026 count. Individual tax returns do not measure the entire institutional rental sector or unique dwellings.
For a household with one investment apartment, a special levy or a mortgage rate increase can change the entire investment decision. Some investors sell, others diversify. We cannot infer a mass exit from anecdotes.
The tax rules have changed
The Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 1) Act 2026 received assent on 26 June 2026. The original article’s description of reform as mere political discussion is outdated.
From 1 July 2027, established residential property acquired from 7:30 pm AEST on 12 May 2026 generally cannot offset rental losses against wages. Losses can be used against residential property income and eligible gains, or carried forward. Existing qualifying holdings are grandfathered and eligible new builds are exempt.
For affected capital gains accruing from 1 July 2027, inflation-based cost-base indexation replaces the general 50% discount, with a 30% minimum tax on relevant gains subject to exceptions. Eligible pre-transition gains retain the existing discount; qualifying new builds have a choice of treatments. The changes extend beyond property to other CGT assets, including investments in shares and funds, with specific fund rules requiring advice.
Sources: Federal Register of Legislation, Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 1) Act 2026; Treasury, Budget 2026–27 tax system changes. Check transitional rules and subsequent amendments with your accountant.
NSW rental law: ownership means responsibility
No-grounds terminations ended in May 2025. Landlords need a lawful reason to end a tenancy, including when selling with vacant possession where the statutory requirements are met. Rent increases are generally limited to once every 12 months. Pet requests and fee-free payment options also have specific requirements. Selling an investment is not simply a matter of asking a tenant to leave. Plan notice, evidence and settlement with your agent and solicitor.
In a building with expensive common property, the strata records are as important as the rental appraisal. My Bondi Junction property guide provides local context for apartment investors.
What does the property actually cost to hold?
Collected rent $50,000
Interest + expenses $101,000
Interest-only loan. Expenses include assumed strata, rates, insurance, maintenance and land tax where applicable. No principal repayments, tax, depreciation or major capital works.
A $1.5 million apartment with $1.2 million debt at 7% incurs $84,000 interest annually. With $50,000 collected rent and $17,000 expenses, the annual shortfall is $51,000. At 8%, it becomes $63,000. That is a real household cash commitment, not a paper loss.
Property versus ETFs: compare equal capital
A broad ETF can offer diversification and exchange-traded liquidity, but market prices fluctuate, fees apply and not every ETF is diversified. Property offers control and leverage, but has transaction costs, concentration and slower exits. Compare the same initial cash and subsequent contributions, not the full property price against the deposit alone.
Pre-tax nominal model. Property loan stays interest-only; selling cost 2%. ETF starts with deposit plus acquisition costs, reinvests returns and receives the same annual cash shortfall as the property. If property generates surplus, that amount is invested in a separate side portfolio at the ETF return. Contributions occur at year-end. No personal tax, CGT, ETF trading fees or inflation adjustment. Returns are assumptions, not forecasts.
Leverage works in both directions
| $1m property, $800k debt | Value change | Equity change before costs |
|---|---|---|
| Price rises 5% | +$50,000 | +25% |
| Price falls 5% | −$50,000 | −25% |
| Price falls 20% | −$200,000 | −100% |
Leverage is not free return. It amplifies losses as well as gains. Renovation or subdivision may create value, but only after approvals, costs and market demand are assessed. My property buying advice starts with the asset and the investor’s ability to hold it.
What I would look for in the Eastern Suburbs
Scarce land in Dover Heights and Bellevue Hill is a different proposition from a new apartment competing with dozens of similar residences. In Rose Bay, the development pipeline matters: new supply can increase choice and pressure resale values, even in a desirable suburb. Examine comparable sales, rental evidence, strata liabilities, planned construction and the likely buyer pool.
Are investors trading out?
Some are rebalancing, but I would not confuse diversification with abandoning real estate. The question is whether the next dollar belongs in the same asset or somewhere else. A household already heavily exposed to Sydney housing may value liquidity more than another leveraged purchase.
If you are considering selling, allow time for the campaign, tenancy arrangements and settlement. Waiting for a recovery is a decision with a cost, particularly if cash flow is negative. My Sydney property selling services focus on realistic pricing and a strategy suited to your circumstances.
My final word
Property is no longer automatic. It is strategic. Discipline matters more than enthusiasm, structure more than speculation, and patience more than prediction. A good investment is one you can afford to hold through a difficult market, not merely one that looks attractive when prices rise.
General educational information from a real estate perspective, not personal financial, legal or tax advice. Consult licensed financial and tax advisers before changing investments.