“Last weekend’s auction results” were two years old.
An article went out under my name reporting a strong weekend of prestige sales: Bellevue Hill, Vaucluse, Paddington, Point Piper. Every one of those sales is real and every one of them is in the public record. They also all happened over the weekend of 17 and 18 June 2023, roughly two years before the piece ran. One was described as off-market when it was a listed private treaty campaign, and one capital gain was stated at over 500 per cent when the register makes it 415. Here is the whole thing checked against the record, and what those same addresses and suburbs have done since.
Six things to correct, starting with the date.
This is the fourth old article I have gone back through, and it is the one I least enjoyed. Stale figures are a mistake. Presenting a two-year-old weekend as the current market is something else, and a reader who checks one address would have found it in about a minute.
Two years out of date
The sales listed underneath that line settled on 17 and 18 June 2023. The clearance and volume figures belong to the same weekend. A clearance rate of 81 per cent would also have been a preliminary number: preliminary rates are collected before late and unreported results come in and routinely revise down by several points. Quoting the preliminary figure without saying so overstates the market by a margin that matters.
Sale real, arithmetic wrong
The house sold at auction on 17 June 2023 for $15,200,000 through TRG after 30 days on market. It previously sold in November 2011 for $2.95 million, and before that in November 1992 for $1.225 million. $15.2 million is 5.15 times $2.95 million, which is a gain of 415 per cent. Multiplying by five and rising five hundred per cent are different things, and the difference here is about $2.6 million.
Not off-market
It was a listed private treaty sale through Ray White Double Bay, recorded on 18 June 2023 at $18,000,000 after 13 days on market. The property had sold in November 2021 for $14 million, so the $4 million gain is right, though it took 19 months rather than two years. Calling a listed campaign off-market is the kind of flourish that makes a reader discount everything around it.
True in June 2023, superseded since
The penthouse at 10/18 Flinton Street, in the converted former Royal Hospital for Women, sold in June 2023 for a reported $20 million-plus. The agent never confirmed the exact figure, so “over $20 million” is as precise as the record allows. It was a record for a Paddington apartment, and it did exceed the terrace market at the time. It has since been passed: the luxury conversion of the former Windsor Castle Hotel sold for $26.85 million in October 2025.
That is a median, not a floor
Around $23.5 million is Point Piper’s median house price over the twelve months to October 2026, calculated on seven sales. Half of those seven were below it. A median on seven transactions tells you almost nothing about the suburb and nothing at all about its smallest homes.
Right then, wrong now
Vaucluse’s house median now sits between about $9.4 million and $9.8 million depending on the source, so it did not stay at $8.375 million. More to the point, it is currently falling: down about 5 per cent over twelve months, with an average vendor discount of 10.3 per cent and 33 days on market. The stability argument has not survived 2026.
Four sources, one suburb, $2.86m apart: the 2023 recovery call scored.
Every street, every verified sale: Bellevue Hill prices by street.
Each of these is a real sale. None of them happened when the article said.
Pick a result to see what the article claimed beside what the sales register shows, with the full ownership history where it exists.
“There’s been little reform in how these policies are reviewed or applied.” The biggest overhaul since the 1990s had started ten weeks earlier.
The 2023 review of the Reserve Bank made 51 recommendations: 24 directed to the Bank, 17 to Government, 10 requiring both. Amendments to the Reserve Bank Act took effect on 1 March 2025. The Bank now runs three boards rather than one, with a dedicated Monetary Policy Board that does nothing but set the cash rate. The meeting calendar went from eleven a year to eight, with longer meetings. The governor holds a press conference after every decision. The post-meeting statement is issued by the Board, not by the governor. Two further recommendations, a published framework for additional policy tools and an external expert advisory group, were due during 2026.
You can argue those changes have not altered a single rate decision. That is a reasonable position and I would listen to it. What you cannot say is that little has changed in how policy is set, in an article published weeks after the change took effect.
There was no recession. What arrived instead was the opposite problem. Inflation turned back up, the Reserve Bank raised the cash rate five times during 2026 to 4.85 per cent, and the squeeze landed on borrowing capacity rather than on employment. Sydney dwelling values are 10.1 per cent below their February 2026 peak after seven consecutive monthly falls, and the total value of Australian housing fell in the June quarter for the first time since 2022. If you had positioned for a mild recession you would have been positioned for falling rates. The error cost more than the date on the auction results did.
“A record $10.1 trillion in Q1 2025.” It was $11.4 trillion, and the real milestone went unmentioned.
The understatement is about $1.3 trillion, roughly the figure from a year earlier. Oddly, the claim attached to it survives the correction: the article said the housing stock was more than four times the size of the economy, which is true on the correct number and would not have been on the one quoted.
Twenty moves, and the lag between each one and the price: rates, inflation and property.
2026 measured against 2022, 2018 and 2008: downturns compared.
“Cash-ready buyers driving strong sales at the top, a credit-restricted middle adjusting.” That has inverted.
It was a fair description of 2021 through 2025 and it is the single claim in the article I would most have defended. In 2026 the top of the Sydney market has fallen first and fallen hardest, while the lower price quartile has held up better. Vaucluse makes the point without any commentary from me.
| Vaucluse houses | As the article had it | Twelve months to late 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Median | $8,375,000, “held steady” | About $9.4m to $9.8m |
| Change over the year | Stability implied | Down about 5% |
| Average vendor discount | Not mentioned | 10.3% off the asking price |
| Days on market | Not mentioned | About 33 |
| Houses sold | Not mentioned | 89 to 108, depending on the register |
Fairweather Street, February 2026
A three-bedroom house on a 625 square metre corner block at 1 Fairweather Street sold at auction for $8,085,000 in February 2026. Across nine verified sales on that street since 2020 the range runs from $8.09 million to $21 million. Same street, same six years, a $13 million spread. That is what the prestige market actually looks like underneath a suburb median.
Bellevue Hill, 2025 to 2026
The house median fell from $12.59 million in 2025 to $9.78 million across the first seven months of 2026 on verified sales, a pullback of roughly 22 per cent. The cash buyers the article relied on did not stop the fall. There are simply fewer of them than the market needs at these prices, and each one now knows it.
Apartments, Sydney-wide
Units are down about 5.6 per cent from the February peak against 10.8 per cent for houses. The buyers who were described as the cautious, credit-restricted middle have turned out to own the part of the market that has lost the least. That is almost exactly the opposite of the article’s conclusion.
The mistake I made is the most common one in property writing. Here is the sum, so neither of us makes it again.
Put in what a property sold for then and now and the number of years between. The tool gives the multiple, the percentage gain and the compound annual rate, which is the only one of the three that lets you compare two properties held for different lengths of time. It starts on the Fairweather Street numbers.
The gain is the later price divided by the earlier one, minus one, times a hundred. The multiple is the same division without the subtraction, which is why a fivefold rise reads as 400 per cent and not 500. None of this allows for stamp duty, holding costs, capital works or selling costs, all of which reduce the real return on a long hold, often substantially.
Content gets produced, dates get carried over, and nobody checks because the underlying facts are true. That is how it happens and it is not an excuse. An agent’s entire value is that when they tell you what the market did last weekend, it did. I have gone back through four older articles now and this is the one that genuinely bothered me, because unlike a typo it reads as current when it is not. If you are reading anything on this site and it quotes a result without a date, tell me and I will date it or pull it.
There is a second thing worth saying about those four sales, which is that they were a genuinely remarkable weekend. June 2023 sat in the middle of a trophy market running at full speed, and a log of that year’s top sales counted close to thirty transactions above $20 million, most of them in a single quarter. Describing that as evidence of a resilient, cash-insulated top end was reasonable at the time. It stopped being reasonable somewhere in the first half of 2026, when the same end of the market started falling faster than everything below it.
If there is a transferable lesson, it is that prestige is not a defence. It is a thinner market with fewer buyers, and thin markets move further in both directions. Bellevue Hill nearly doubled in five years and gave back $2.8 million of its median in seven months. Vaucluse is holding a bigger number than it did in 2023 and is conceding more than ten per cent off the ask to get sales away. Both of those things can be true, and the only way to know where your own property sits inside that is to look at the comparable sales, with dates on them.
Whether the top really is immune: the prestige market tested.
Scorecards, suburb guides and street data: Alan’s articles.
Want the comparable sales for your street, with dates on every one of them?
Not a median, not a headline result from a weekend two years ago. The actual sales nearest to yours, when they happened, what they conceded off the ask, and what that means for your position right now. Thirty-five years in the Eastern Suburbs, every campaign run personally.
35+ years in Sydney’s Eastern Suburbs
- Property records for 10 Fairweather Street, Bellevue Hill: sold at auction 17 June 2023 for $15,200,000 through TRG after 30 days listed; previously sold November 2011 for $2.95 million by private treaty and November 1992 for $1.225 million at auction. Five bedrooms, six bathrooms, 753 square metre block.
- Property records for 26 Olphert Avenue, Vaucluse: sold by private treaty 18 June 2023 for $18,000,000 through Ray White Double Bay after 13 days listed; previously sold November 2021 for $14,000,000 and May 1999 for $2.565 million. Six bedrooms, four bathrooms.
- Domain, June 2023: the penthouse at 10/18 Flinton Street, Paddington, in the converted former Royal Hospital for Women, sold “in line of $20 million-plus”, a record for a Paddington apartment; the previous Paddington record of $12 million had been broken earlier that month by the $14 million sale of “Brompton” at 238–240 Glenmore Road, a sale that subsequently did not settle. Domain, 2026: the suburb benchmark of $26.85 million was set in October 2025 by the luxury conversion of the former Windsor Castle Hotel.
- Contemporaneous market commentary, June 2023: Sydney’s trophy market had recorded close to thirty sales above $20 million that year, more than twenty of them in that quarter.
- property.carto.au Sydney house price rankings, twelve months to 15 October 2026: Point Piper median house price $23.5 million on 7 sales; Vaucluse $9.80 million on 108 sales. propertyvalue.com.au, Vaucluse houses, twelve months to late 2026: median value $9.4 million, 89 properties sold, 33 average days on market, average vendor discount 10.3 per cent, median sale price change over one year down 5.0 per cent.
- Weiss Real Estate, Bellevue Hill Property Prices by Street 2020–2026 (verified sales register): suburb house median $12.59 million in 2025 falling to $9.78 million across the first seven months of 2026; Fairweather Street nine house sales at a $14.80 million median, from $8.09 million to $21.00 million. Goldman Bros, February 2026: 1 Fairweather Street, Bellevue Hill, three bedrooms on 625 square metres, bought at auction for $8,085,000.
- ABS Total Value of Dwellings: March quarter 2025 total value $11,366.4 billion, up $130.7 billion or 1.2 per cent, with the national mean dwelling price passing $1,000,000 for the first time at $1,002,500; March quarter 2026 $12,772.6 billion, up 11.9 per cent over the year; June quarter 2026 down $34.1 billion or 0.3 per cent to $12.68 trillion, the first fall since 2022, with NSW down 2.0 per cent. ABS National Accounts: nominal GDP of $736.6 billion in the March quarter 2026, an annual rate near $2.95 trillion.
- Reserve Bank of Australia, Progress Report on the Review of the Reserve Bank of Australia: the review made 51 recommendations (24 to the RBA, 17 to Government, 10 joint); amendments to the Reserve Bank Act 1959 took effect 1 March 2025, introducing a three-board governance structure including a dedicated Monetary Policy Board; the Board moved from eleven to eight longer meetings a year from 2024, with a post-meeting press conference by the governor and the post-decision statement issued by the Board; two further recommendations were expected during 2026.
- Cotality Home Value Index: Sydney dwelling values 10.1 per cent below their February 2026 peak at 1 November 2026 after seven consecutive monthly falls; houses down about 10.8 per cent and units about 5.6 per cent. Reserve Bank of Australia: cash rate 4.85 per cent at 3 November 2026 after five increases during 2026.
- Alan Weiss, “There is much speculation about the sustainability of the current market” (the original article this corrects), and Weiss Real Estate campaign records, Eastern Suburbs.
Suburb medians and vendor discount figures differ between providers depending on the window, the register and the inclusion rules, and are shown here as ranges where sources disagree. A median calculated on a small number of sales, as in Point Piper, is not a reliable guide to any individual property. Calculator outputs are arithmetic on the figures entered and take no account of stamp duty, holding costs, capital works or selling costs. Includes Alan Weiss’s personal views. General information only; not financial, tax or legal advice.