The suburban shift, five years on: the move out of the city was right, and the reason I gave for it was wrong.
In 2021 I wrote that working from home had untethered the commute, that families were leaving inner-city apartments for houses on the fringe, and that they could upgrade without increasing their mortgages because money was cheap. Five years on, the first half of that has held up better than almost any call I’ve made: capital-to-regional migration hit its highest level on record in the March 2026 quarter, and Sydney alone accounted for 52% of the national outflow to the regions in June. The second half did not survive contact with the Reserve Bank. The cheap-upgrade logic depended entirely on a 0.10% cash rate, and at 4.85% the same move costs about 70% more each month to service. Here’s the scorecard, a calculator that runs the 2021 trade at today’s rates, and the part of the thesis that quietly reversed.
The migration held. The economics behind it didn’t.
Two things happened at once after 2021 and they pull in opposite directions. The behavioural change was real and durable: hybrid work stuck at around a third of workers, and the flow of people out of Sydney has not only continued but reached new records this year. At the same time the financial case that made the move painless was demolished by thirteen rate rises and then five more. A family making the identical swap today borrows the same amount and pays roughly 70% more every month for it.
Sources: RBA; Regional Movers Index (Commonwealth Bank and Regional Australia Institute), March and June quarters 2026; ABS working arrangements; PropTrack Home Price Index, February 2026; Cotality Home Value Index, October 2026.
Seven claims from 2021, against what the data now shows.
I’d rather mark my own homework in public than quietly rewrite it. Three of these were right, two half right, and two were wrong in ways worth understanding, because the same reasoning is being used again today.
Not a blip. The Regional Movers Index hit its highest reading on record in the March 2026 quarter, with capital-to-regional moves running 29.7% above the reverse flow, and the June quarter matched the 2021 pandemic peak. Sydney is the largest single source.
The best advice in the original and it has aged perfectly. The research now points the same way: coastal regions close to major cities, Newcastle, Wollongong, the Gold Coast and Geelong, are the ones flourishing, while small remote inland centres struggle. Connection still sets the price.
Timeless, and more true in a correction than a boom. The better property in the better street falls less and recovers first, which is the whole argument for buying quality over quantity when the budget forces a choice.
True then, and the mechanism was right, but it is not a one-way property of the premium segment. The top quartile is simply the most volatile: it led the market up in 2021 and it is leading it down now, with Sydney houses off 10.8% over the year against 5.6% for units. Reading that 2021 figure as a reason to stretch into the top bracket would have cost you.
It changed, eventually. Sydney listings are up 19.3% year on year and stock over 180 days is up 41.6%. But the patience I recommended would have meant waiting through 2021 and 2022, when prices rose 25% in a single year. Being right about the destination is not the same as being right about the timing.
This was true at a 0.10% cash rate and nowhere else. The same swap today requires the same loan at roughly 7.1% instead of 2.4%, which is about 70% more in monthly repayments, and a given income now borrows about 39% less than it did in 2021. The calculator below runs the arithmetic.
The clearest miss. Walkable inner suburbs came back hard once the restrictions ended, and the premium is now on neighbourhood rather than floor space: inner-west agents report Redfern house prices up 20.6% over the past year and Chippendale apartments up 20.1%, in suburbs with walk scores in the nineties. The home no longer has to provide everything, because the street does.
Scoring is Alan Weiss’s own, against the sources listed at the end. Inner-west suburb figures as reported by local agents from Cotality data, June 2026.
Thirty-six years of rates against Sydney prices, and the four episodes that broke the pattern: interest rates and house prices.
Ten investor predictions from the same period, marked honestly: the investor outlook, scored.
Sell the apartment, buy the house. Same loan, very different repayment.
This is the move the original described: an inner-city apartment traded for a freestanding house further out. The loan it requires has barely changed. What changed is what the loan costs. Set your two numbers and compare the monthly repayment at 2021’s 2.4% against today’s 7.1%, with duty and selling costs in the middle where they belong.
Indicative. Selling costs 2.2% plus $25,000; moving and legals $20,000; duty on the Revenue NSW 2026–27 scale. Capacity assumes repayments capped at 30% of gross income at the assessed rate of 10.1%, which is a simplification of what a lender actually does. Not credit advice.
Which to do first, and what a long settlement is worth: buy first or sell first.
What five rate rises did to the number in your head: buying mistakes in 2026.
Not anywhere with a view. Coastal, and close enough to come back.
The 2021 assumption was that remote work would scatter people anywhere with broadband. It didn’t. The destinations that won are coastal centres within reach of a capital, and university research published this year found the same thing: regional centres that are coastal and near major cities will flourish, while small remote inland centres struggle to hold population. Hybrid work means two or three days in the office, which is a commute you can do from Newcastle but not from the far west.
Regional Movers Index. Green marks destinations within about two hours of a capital city. The Central Coast, the Hunter and the Illawarra all gain residents from Sydney, though not enough to offset Sydney’s total outflow. Toowoomba’s intake rose 236% on a year earlier.
Light, layout and the study that actually works: renovating for hybrid work.
Why apartments near the Junction interchange held up while the fringe stretched: Bondi Junction apartments.
Three of the four still stand. One needs replacing, and one is new.
The original closed with four rules for buying something that would hold its value. They were good rules. Here they are with five more years of evidence against them.
Buy above the suburb median, in the better street
Holds up. The better property falls less and recovers first, which matters far more in a correction than it did in a boom. The qualification I’d add in 2026: above the median for the suburb, not above your capacity. The gap between those two has widened by 39% since the original was written.
Within walking distance of shops, transport and schools
This was a tip in 2021; it is now the single biggest driver of relative performance. Inner-west suburbs with walk scores in the nineties have seen double-digit annual growth while the market overall fell. If you take one rule from the original into 2026, take this one.
“A bigger yard, a view, a dream entertainment area”
The 2021 wish list was built for lockdown, when the home had to be everything. Entertainment areas and vast lawns have not held their premium the way a second bathroom, a genuine study and off-street parking have. Buy the features a 2031 buyer will pay for, not the ones a 2021 buyer wanted.
Check what can be built next door. The low- and mid-rise reforms allow more apartments around 171 station and town centres, including several in the East. Proximity to a transport hub now cuts both ways: it supports your resale and it may put a six-storey building across the road. The planning controls are public and take ten minutes to check.
Eight Eastern Suburbs precincts, with heights and what’s actually viable: the LMR reforms in the East.
I’ve watched this market since the mid-1980s and I’ve seen three versions of the exodus story, in the early nineties, after 2008 and again after 2020. Each time the commentary treats it as a permanent change in how Australians want to live, and each time what is actually driving it is price. The pandemic gave people permission and working from home gave them the mechanism, but the reason a family leaves Bondi for Lake Macquarie is that the same money buys three times the house. That calculation did not reverse when the offices reopened; it got stronger, which is why the Regional Movers Index is at a record rather than a memory.
Where I was wrong was in treating cheap money as part of the landscape rather than a moment. The whole emotional appeal of the 2021 piece was that you could have more for the same, and that was an artefact of a 0.10% cash rate. Today the same family can still buy three times the house, but they will pay roughly 70% more each month to do it, and their capacity to borrow is 39% smaller. The move still makes sense for plenty of people. It just has to be justified on space, lifestyle and price per square metre, not on the mortgage being painless. And if you are staying in the East, the lesson from the suburbs is the one worth importing: the walk to the shops is doing more for your property’s value than the extra bedroom is.
Priced to the buyers who exist now, with a settlement built around your next move: my selling service.
Selling here and buying there, negotiated together: selling and buying in one move.
Thinking about the same move? Run it at today’s rates first.
What your apartment would clear this month, what the swap leaves after duty and costs, and whether the repayment works at 7.1% rather than the number you remember. Thirty-five years of reading this market, including the calls that didn’t age well. If you’re buying in the East rather than leaving it, see my buying service.
35+ years in Sydney’s Eastern Suburbs
- Regional Movers Index (Commonwealth Bank and Regional Australia Institute): March 2026 quarter, capital-to-regional movement at its highest recorded level, 29.7% above the reverse flow; June 2026 quarter matched the record set in June 2021, with moves out of capitals 30% higher than moves in and Sydney accounting for 52% of the net outflow; destination shares Sunshine Coast 8.7–8.9%, Greater Geelong 6.8%, Fraser Coast 3.9%, Lake Macquarie 3.6%, Moorabool 3.4%; Toowoomba up 236% year on year.
- University of Adelaide research on remote work and settlement patterns, 2026: coastal regional centres close to major cities are expected to flourish while small remote inland centres struggle. ABS working arrangements: about 36% of workers work from home at least some of the time.
- Reserve Bank of Australia: cash rate 0.10% (November 2020 to May 2022) and 4.85% (3 November 2026); average new variable owner-occupier rate about 7.1% today against roughly 2.4% in 2021. APRA serviceability buffer of 3 percentage points.
- Cotality Home Value Index, October 2026: Sydney houses −10.8% and units −5.6% over the year; dwellings −10.1% from the February 2026 peak; Sydney values rose 25.3% in 2021. PropTrack Home Price Index, February 2026: regional prices +10.5% year on year. SQM Research, October 2026: Sydney total listings +19.3%, listings over 180 days +41.6%.
- Inner-west suburb figures (Redfern houses +20.6%, Chippendale apartments +20.1%, Darlington +16.9%, Alexandria three-bedroom apartments +25.3% in 2025) as reported by local agents from Cotality data, June 2026. CoreLogic value-bracket figures for the three months to February 2021 as cited in the original article; CoreLogic is now Cotality.
- Alan Weiss, “The suburban shift: unlocking better homes and greater value in post-Covid Australia” (the original article this scores), and Weiss Real Estate campaign records.
Scoring and weightings are Alan Weiss’s own judgement. Calculator outputs are indicative and not credit advice. Includes Alan Weiss’s personal views. General information only; not financial, tax or legal advice.