Why Every Property Investor Should Be Alarmed by the Government’s Proposed Super Tax on Unrealised Gains

WEISS REAL ESTATE · INVESTMENT INSIGHTS

Division 296: What the new super tax means for property investors

By Alan Weiss | Updated 12 November 2026

Imagine owning two investment apartments in Rose Bay through your self-managed super fund (SMSF). Their value rises by $500,000, but you have not sold either property. Will you owe tax on that paper gain? Under the original Division 296 proposal, this was a genuine concern. Under the law now in force, the answer is different.

As a real estate agent, my concern is how changes to retirement savings influence property decisions. The revised law is less punitive towards unrealised property gains, but investors still need to understand the implications of holding valuable, illiquid assets inside super.

$3mLower individual balance threshold
$10mHigher individual balance threshold
1 July 2026Commencement

What changed from the original proposal?

Division 296 is now law. It applies from the 2026–27 financial year, with initial assessments expected in 2027–28. The final design uses realised earnings rather than annual paper gains, and both thresholds are indexed to inflation.

Feature Original proposal Current law
Unrealised gains Included Excluded from earnings base
Thresholds $3m, fixed $3m and $10m, CPI indexed
Additional tax 15% 15% and 25% on relevant earnings portions
Start 1 July 2025 1 July 2026

The thresholds apply to each individual’s total super balance across funds, not the gross value of a property or the combined balance of a couple’s SMSF. Rent, interest, dividends and realised capital gains can contribute to the statutory earnings calculation, subject to adjustments and attribution rules. The additional tax is assessed to the member personally; eligible amounts may be released from super to pay it.

How the rates work

For 2026–27, the additional rate is 15% on the earnings portion attributable to balances above $3 million and up to $10 million, and 25% on the portion above $10 million. In accumulation phase these correspond to nominal combined rates of 30% and 40% respectively, not a flat tax on the entire balance. Actual fund tax can differ, including in retirement phase.

Rose Bay: two apartments, one important distinction

Consider an illustrative debt-free SMSF portfolio that increases in value from $3 million to $3.5 million. Assume one member owns the entire beneficial interest, has no other super and has a total super balance of $3.5 million at 30 June 2027. Gross annual rent is $140,000 (4% of $3.5 million); assume $40,000 in deductible expenses and no sale, leaving $100,000 of simplified attributable Division 296 earnings.

Unrealised appreciation $500,000
Illustrative realised earnings $100,000
Proportion above $3m 14.29%
Additional tax: $100,000 × 14.29% × 15% $2,143

The $500,000 paper gain does not itself attract Division 296 tax. It can nevertheless increase the member’s balance and therefore the proportion of realised earnings exposed to the tax. If the same $3.5 million were split equally between two members with no other super, neither would exceed the threshold in this example.

When a sale changes the picture

Assume instead that attributable Division 296 earnings reach $400,000 in a year when the same $3.5 million balance applies, after all relevant adjustments. The illustrative additional tax becomes $8,571. This is why the timing of a sale, the cost base and the member’s balance matter.

Rental earnings example — $2,143

Higher realised earnings example — $8,571

These are hypothetical figures, not Rose Bay market yield estimates or individual tax advice. Review local comparable transactions in Alan’s property market articles.

Estimate the additional tax

Illustrative additional tax: $2,143

First-year simplified calculation using 2026–27 thresholds. Excludes special rules, losses, exemptions and ordinary fund tax. Not an assessment.

What property investors should do now

1. Review liquidity, not just net worth

A valuable apartment does not automatically provide cash. Allow for vacancies, strata levies, repairs, insurance, pension payments and tax. A sale can generate taxable earnings in the same year as other cash obligations. Maintain a cash buffer rather than assuming the fund can borrow freely; SMSF borrowing is tightly restricted.

2. Document valuations and the transitional cost base

Market valuations remain important for member balances and SMSF reporting. Ask your accountant whether the transitional election to reset eligible asset cost bases to 1 July 2026 market values for Division 296 purposes is available and appropriate. It does not reset ordinary CGT cost bases. Obtain defensible valuation evidence and confirm election deadlines with your adviser.

3. Consider the whole retirement strategy

Compare keeping the property with selling or diversifying. Transferring assets out of super may trigger tax, transfer duty and compliance issues; access to super is also subject to release conditions. Do not restructure solely to avoid a headline tax rate. A licensed financial adviser, SMSF accountant and solicitor can assess your circumstances.

4. Understand the property market before selling

In the Eastern Suburbs, a sale price depends on the individual building, condition, outlook, strata liabilities and competing stock. My selling service focuses on comparable evidence and negotiation, not pressure to sell. If you are considering a replacement investment, explore my buying service.

My view

The removal of unrealised gains is a meaningful improvement. I no longer see a case for telling every SMSF property investor that rising property values alone will produce an immediate tax bill. But the law is a reminder that tax settings can change over a long investment horizon. The right response is to understand your numbers, maintain liquidity and make property decisions based on your retirement objectives rather than headlines.

Planning your next property decision?

Speak with Weiss Real Estate about the market value and sale prospects of your Eastern Suburbs property. For tax and superannuation advice, consult your qualified advisers.

Explore selling with Weiss Real Estate

Research and important information

Sources: Parliament of Australia, Bills Digest No. 48, 2025–26, Treasury Laws Amendment (Building a Stronger and Fairer Super System) Bill 2026; Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation, Division 296 tax: what it is and what it means for you, 27 August 2026; SuperGuide, Division 296 super tax explained, November 2026; Cameron Harrison, Beyond the Headlines: Inside Division 296, 2026. General property commentary only; not financial, legal or tax advice.

Related Posts